EDR vs antivirus: what UK businesses actually need in 2026
TL;DR: Antivirus stops known threats. EDR catches what gets past it. You need both.
- Antivirus blocks known malware, but struggles with new ransomware, fileless attacks and hackers using legitimate admin tools.
- EDR (endpoint detection and response) watches device behaviour, flags suspicious activity and lets responders isolate a machine in seconds.
- EDR is only as good as the people watching it. MDR adds a 24/7 team that investigates and acts on alerts for you.
- Knowall layers Huntress Managed EDR on top of Microsoft Defender, monitored 24/7, in our Security Suite from £12 per user.
Most businesses we speak to already have antivirus and assume that means they are protected. It is a reasonable assumption, but the way attacks work has changed, and the EDR vs antivirus question now comes up in almost every insurance renewal and security review. This guide explains what each one does, where antivirus falls short, how EDR and MDR differ, and what a UK small or mid-sized business actually needs in 2026.
What is the difference between EDR and antivirus?
Antivirus blocks known threats before they run. EDR (endpoint detection and response) watches how devices behave, spots attacks that slip past antivirus, and lets someone isolate a device and shut the attack down. They are not rivals. Most UK businesses need both, plus a team watching the EDR alerts around the clock.
What does antivirus do, and where does it fall short?
Antivirus (sometimes called endpoint protection or next-generation antivirus) checks files and programs against what it knows to be malicious. Modern products such as Microsoft Defender Antivirus, which is built into Windows, also use cloud lookups and machine learning to catch close variants of known malware. For everyday threats like a dodgy email attachment or an infected download, it does a good job.
The problem is that it is designed to answer one question: “Is this file bad?” Today’s attackers often avoid giving it anything to find.
Ransomware and brand-new malware
Ransomware gangs constantly repackage their tools so that each version looks new. If antivirus has never seen the file before and it does not behave in an obviously malicious way at launch, it can run. By the time the encryption starts, it may be too late.
Hands-on attackers using your own tools
Many serious attacks involve a person, not just a program. After stealing a password, an attacker logs in and uses legitimate tools already on the machine, such as PowerShell, remote desktop or backup software. None of these are malware, so antivirus has nothing to block. This is often called “living off the land”, and it is how attackers quietly move around a network for days before launching ransomware.
No record of what happened
When antivirus blocks something, you get a single alert. When it misses something, you get nothing. There is no timeline showing how the attacker got in, what they touched or whether they are still there.
What is endpoint detection and response (EDR)?
EDR is software that runs on every laptop, desktop and server (the “endpoints”) and continuously records what is happening: processes starting, files changing, network connections, user logins and registry changes. It looks for patterns of behaviour that suggest an attack, even when every individual tool involved is legitimate.
When it spots something suspicious, EDR does three things antivirus cannot:
- Detects behaviour, not just files. For example, Word launching PowerShell, which then tries to disable backups and delete shadow copies.
- Responds. A responder can isolate the device from the network, kill processes and remove persistence so the attacker cannot come back.
- Investigates. It keeps a timeline, so you can see how the attack started and confirm it is fully cleaned up.
EDR vs antivirus: how do they compare?
| Antivirus | EDR | |
|---|---|---|
| Main job | Prevent known malware from running | Detect and respond to suspicious behaviour |
| How it decides | Signatures, reputation and file analysis | Behaviour across processes, users and network activity |
| New or unknown malware | Limited | Strong, based on what the malware does |
| Hands-on attackers | Rarely detected | Designed to catch them |
| Response options | Quarantine or delete a file | Isolate devices, kill processes, remove persistence |
| Investigation | Single alert | Full attack timeline |
| Needs people? | Mostly automatic | Yes, someone must review and act on alerts |
The takeaway: antivirus is your front door lock, and EDR is the alarm system and CCTV. You would not remove the lock because you installed an alarm.
What is the difference between EDR and MDR?
That last row of the table matters more than any feature list. EDR produces alerts, and alerts at 2am on a Saturday are only useful if someone reads them. Ransomware groups know this, which is why so many attacks are launched outside office hours.
MDR (managed detection and response) is EDR plus a team of security analysts who monitor it 24/7. They investigate each alert, separate genuine threats from noise and take action, such as isolating a laptop, without waiting for you to wake up. For a business without its own security operations centre (SOC), EDR without MDR often means a powerful tool that nobody is watching.
Do small and mid-sized businesses need EDR?
For most organisations, yes. Attackers do not only target large companies. The UK Government’s Cyber Security Breaches Survey 2025/2026 found that 43% of businesses identified a cyber breach or attack in the previous 12 months. Smaller firms are often seen as easier targets because they have fewer defences.
Cyber insurance
Insurers now routinely ask whether you run EDR on all devices and whether it is monitored around the clock. A “no” can mean higher premiums, exclusions or a declined policy. If you have a renewal coming up, check the proposal form carefully.
Cyber Essentials
Malware protection is one of the five technical controls in the NCSC’s Cyber Essentials Requirements for IT Infrastructure v3.3, which has applied to new assessments since April 2026. Correctly configured antivirus can meet that control on its own, so EDR is not mandatory for Cyber Essentials certification. Think of Cyber Essentials as the baseline and EDR as the next layer for the attacks it is not designed to stop.
Regulated and high-value sectors
If you handle client money, health data, legal files or payment card details, or you supply larger organisations that audit their supply chain, EDR with 24/7 monitoring is quickly becoming an expected control rather than a nice extra.
How does Knowall protect your devices?
We do not ask you to throw away what already works. Microsoft Defender Antivirus is built into Windows and is a solid first layer, so we keep it and manage it properly. On top, we deploy Huntress Managed EDR, which adds its own behavioural detection and is backed by a 24/7 SOC whose analysts investigate and respond to threats around the clock. Huntress also manages Defender’s configuration and exclusions centrally, so the two work as one system rather than two separate products.
In practice, that means:
- Antivirus and EDR on every Windows and Mac device and server
- Human analysts watching for threats 24/7, including weekends and bank holidays
- Compromised devices isolated and cleaned up, with a plain-English report of what happened
- Our own team following up on anything that needs changes to your wider IT
Managed EDR is included in the Knowall Security Suite, from £12 per user per month, alongside the other layers that make it effective. If you are not sure where your current setup stands, our free cyber security assessment will show you the gaps.
Frequently asked questions
Antivirus is still essential, but it was built for a time when threats arrived as files. Today’s attackers log in, look around and use your own tools against you, and catching that takes behavioural monitoring and people ready to act at any hour. Getting both layers in place, and making sure someone is watching, is one of the most effective security upgrades a growing business can make. If you want to talk it through, our managed cyber security team is happy to help.
